Protein Coconut Cream Pie Chia Pudding Cups

These protein-packed coconut cream pie chia pudding cups are the perfect make-ahead dessert (or breakfast!) Not only are they full of amazing flavors like vanilla bean and creamy coconut, but the protein content is next level thanks to the chia seeds and protein powder. 

To really go out with a bang, we topped ’em with a delicious coconut whip that sets this creamy chia pudding apart from the rest.

These Coconut Cream Pie Chia Pudding cups are part of our 2024 Protein Dessert Series. If you make this recipe, snap a photo and upload it to the comment section to enter for a chance to win the Herbivore Clearly Bright Serum Duo. You’ll also be entered into a greater giveaway for this series — a $500 lululemon shopping spree! Winners will be chosen on January 31.

If there is one recipe on Fit Foodie Finds that the whole team is obsessed with, it’s this coconut cream pie chia pudding. It legit tastes like coconut cream pie, is sweet without being too sweet, and is the perfect protein-packed dessert (or breakfast!).

What’s In Coconut Cream Pie Chia Pudding?

• Chia seeds: black chia seeds absorb all the creamy coconut milk, making a luscious pudding-like texture.
• Vanilla protein powder: we used Vital Protein Vanilla Coconut Collagen Protein Powder for a boost of protein and flavor! Feel free to use your favorite protein powder if you wish.
• Unsweetened coconut milk: use canned or cartoned full-fat coconut milk for best results.
• Agave syrup: agave syrup is used for both the chia pudding and coconut whip. It’s an excellent natural sweetener that pairs well with the coconut flavors.
• Shredded coconut: you’ll again want to use unsweetened coconut so that the pudding doesn’t become too sweet. It adds a lot of extra coconut flavor!
• Coconut chips: similar to coconut flakes, these chips will be the perfect crunchy topping for this chia seed pudding recipe.
• Coconut cream: this is whipped to perfection to make the tasty coconut whip topping. Make sure to refrigerate to separate the cream from the liquid before using.

Variations and Substitutions

Of course, you can pave your own scrumptious path with this creamy coconut chia pudding. For instance, you could replace the vanilla protein powder with chocolate protein powder, or add some cacao powder to make a chocolate chia seed pudding! Note that the brand of protein powder will change the flavor slightly. 

You could also use maple syrup or honey instead of agave syrup. The flavor will change slightly based on what sweetener is used, but it will still be delicious. If you don’t have any coconut milk on hand, other plant-based milk like almond milk, oat milk, soy milk, or cashew milk work just fine. Just know that the flavor and texture will vary from using coconut milk.

There is also always room for a little bit of fun! Additions like fresh fruit, chocolate chips, or even peanut butter can give this chia seed pudding a unique twist. Go ahead and experiment to find your favorite flavor combination!

Storage + Freezer Directions

Use a ½ cup scoop to separate the coconut cream pie chia pudding into 4-6 airtight containers, preferably glass. Store in the refrigerator for up to 5 days.

To freeze, place in a freezer-safe, airtight container and store in the freezer for up to 3 to 4 weeks.

What to Serve with Coconut Cream Pie Chia Pudding

Just as there are plenty of different ways to enjoy these creamy puddings, there are also a variety of great dishes to pair them with. We’ll focus on breakfast since this recipe is perfect for meal prepping your breakfasts. 

Here are a few of our favorites: